More than 30 people joined archaeologist Ian McHardy to explore the possible story of a lost stone circle in Stornoway on Thursday and Friday (October 29, 30).
This event – part of the Faclan (Hebridean Book Festival) Fringe – was in two parts: first, a table-top study beginning in Stornoway Library to look at historic maps; and second, exploring in the field some of the questions surrounding the postulated Stone Circle on Gallow’s Hill.
Up to now the Gallows Hill “circle” has not been recorded as a classic stone circle. What Ian McHardy was dealing with is the scheduled prehistoric monument on Cnoc na Croich, and the official record identifies it as a Neolithic chambered cairn, not a megalithic stone circle.
The supposed cairn spreads over a sub-circular area about 30 m across. Its edge is marked by three upright stones and one fallen stone – seen up to now as the remnants of a peristalith that once circled the monument. However, Ian McHardy believes this misunderstands the evidence on the ground.
The chamber survives in outline and is roughly 5 m long and up to 1.25 m wide inside, formed by seven large edge-set stones. The monument is a Scheduled Ancient Monument, Canmore ID 71507 / SM6550.
The hill was later incorporated into the Matheson/Lews Castle designed landscape, with tree planting and a track circling the summit; visible there is a modern cairn which was supposedly built in 1902 to commemorate King Edward VII’s visit, probably on the traditional gallows site.
However, what Ian McHardy has identified is a long-overlooked reference on the torn edges of a Stornoway map dating back to 1785. That clearly refers to a stone circle on Gallows Hill and the torn edge of the map (which suffered water damage at some point) clearly includes a diagram of a circle and avenue reminiscent of the layout of the Calanais Stones.
The map 1785 map was commissioned by and dedicated to Francis Mackenzie, 1st Baron Seaforth, and is the earliest detailed record of named proprietors in Stornoway. As is customary for estate maps such as this, each land parcel has been carefully measured (written out in Acres, Rods, and Falls) and its broad agricultural use or potential has been described. The distinction into Arable, Pasture, Moor & Sand, and Moss are the main categories, but there are more detailed descriptions too. Therefore, it’s description of a Stone Circle is very valuable and unlikely to be fanciful.
Sadly, none of the subsequent local maps covered this spot – and by the time of first Ordnance Survey map in 1849, there’s no reference to any remains on the spot.
During the Stornoway Library sessions Ian McHardy sought possible explanations for the demolition or removal of the monument by any of the three proprietors over that period – Francis Mackenzie; Lady Hood Mackenzie; and Sir James Matheson.
During the visits to the hill itself, Ian McHardy was able to point out the location of various megaliths – Calanais-like – which appeared to have been tipped down the hillside and are now covered by trees.
Ian McHardy sees the sizeable stone circle as a “signpost” to a route made by other known circles which crossed the island to Calanais…welcoming visitors to the secure anchorage in what is now Stornoway Harbour and setting them on their route to the widely renowned Calanais complex of circles. Recent archaeological work in Orkney, Wiltshire and elsewhere has shown the scale of population movement and trade in the Neolithic period.
Of course, the official record still classifies the monument as a Neolithic chambered cairn; Ian McHardy’s argument is that the 1785 map and his field evidence together point to a different and larger monument.
Ian McHardy is a freelance archaeologist who has lived and worked on Lewis for more than 20 years and spent two years as the St Kilda Archaeologist. He is a fully qualified Archaeologist with a BSc (Hons) from Glasgow University and an Associate of the Chartered Institute for Archaeologists.
