The conflict over the future of the work of community landowner Stòras Uibhist is reaching new levels of intensity following a decision to delay this year's AGM into next year.
At the centre of the row is a major concern for "the silenced majority" – as the protestors term themselves – is that the election of an Interim Board at the EGM of Sealladh na Beinne Mòire in April this year was approved by members on condition that it was a temporary board that would be dissolved and a full-scale AGM held in three to four months.
Now former board member Mary Schmoller – who once chaired the board – is saying that the decision that the Sealladh na Beinne Mòire Board took to postpone the Annual General Meeting scheduled for 17 November 2026 raises serious concerns about governance, accountability and the rights of members.
This is part of a long-running pattern of dissent among those involved with the company.
-
Board control and legitimacy — who properly speaks for SnBM and its subsidiaries?
-
The charity-conversion question — repeatedly raised as an unresolved strategic issue, and used by both sides as a criticism of the other.
-
CEO/leadership disputes — suspensions, reinstatements and competing claims about who has authority to appoint or direct senior staff.
-
Subsidiary-board manoeuvres — the use of company-law (emergency meetings, co-options, quorum claims) to try to change the balance of power.
-
Community-level exhaustion — the language in media coverage (“vexatious”, “overt hostility”, “derail”) suggests a community organisation whose energy is being consumed by internal warfare.
Mary says that: "Only weeks ago, members were invited to nominate candidates for election to the Board on the basis that the AGM would take place on 17 November.
"Members acted on that information. Nominations were submitted, candidates agreed to stand and members reasonably expected that they would soon be able to elect a new Board and participate in the democratic governance of their Company.
"Members have now been told that the AGM and election process must be postponed because legal advice is being sought regarding the eligibility of one nominee."
The delay is particularly important, she says, "because the AGM is not merely an administrative requirement. It is the principal opportunity for members to hold directors to account, scrutinise the management of the Company, review its performance and elect those who will govern it in the future.
"The issue is not simply that the Board remains in office longer than anticipated. The issue is that the temporary nature of the arrangement was one of the conditions upon which members agreed to support it in the first place.
"Many members supported the interim arrangements because they were presented as a clean break from aspects of the Company's previous governance that had undermined trust and confidence.
"This debate is not about personalities. Nor is it about any single candidate. It is about whether the constitutional rules of the Company are being followed and whether members are being permitted to exercise the rights those rules were designed to protect."
